Commenting on this blog, one of my friend and a highly respected senior journalist wrote to me, "Please keep in mind that your readers are from all sections of the society and faith denominations. My question is how much would you like to focus on your 'Muslimness' and why? Although his other comments were very encouraging, but they forced me to search an answer for a question that I never thought of, "How much would I focus on my 'Muslimness'?
The Indian Muslims are forced to live with dual identities. I never heard anyone using the term 'Indian Hindus'. Apparently, it is presumed that all Hindus are Indians or all Indians are Hindus. But Muslims in this country are both Indians and also Muslims. A journalist or other professionals like me even have triple identities. I'm a journalist, an Indian and also a Muslim.
A website has published a beautiful photograph of a burkha clad woman holding the tri-colour flag on the Republic Day. However, it went with the caption, "Indian first, Muslim next". Should we appreciate the caption or question the mindset of that publisher? I never read a photo caption that said, "Indian first, Hindu next or Christian or Sikh next." Why is it so that only Muslims are awarded these dual or triple identities? Why is it so that only Muslims are asked to prioritise these identities? Like other Indians, why can't their nationality overshadow their religion and profession?
I must admit that I'm not too religious. I don't offer 'Namaz' five times a day. I'm not wearing a beard. I listen to music and watch movies. I'm not fully familiar with the history of Islam or other religious aspects. Due to these lackings and habits, my relatives feel that I'm 'not a true Muslim'. However, I don't miss Friday prayers; I observe fast during 'Ramzan' and very often use phrases like 'Insha Allah' or 'Masha Allah'. These things make some colleagues and friends of mine believe that I'm a 'fundamentalist.' I'm still unsure of which tag suits me the best -- 'not a true Muslim' or a 'fundamentalist'.
Whether we accept it or not, India is slowly becoming a Hindu nation. Almost all official functions of our secular country start with lighting up of a lamp, as per the Hindu rituals. The ground-breaking ceremonies of any project starts with a 'bhumi-puja'. Religious festivals like Deepavali and Dussera have unofficially became national festivals. The Prime Minister himself participate in the Ramleela Ground programme in New Delhi.
Almost all Hindi channels have now become 'Hindu' channels. Besides having dedicated shows on Hinduism, they devote most of the time covering events like Amarnath Yatra, Shivratri, Kumbh Mela or Brahmotsavam in Tirupati. Infact, many channels did a series of reports to prove that all the mythological stories of Mahabharata and Ramayana were true. There is nothing wrong in doing this. All Indians have freedom to practice and propagate their religion, but in a secular country, I believe, no particular religion should enjoy official patronage.
At a time when people are identifying themselves with their religion, then what is wrong if Muslims talk about their religion and the community. This is neither communalism nor anti-nationalism. As a journalist, I think it is my duty to highlight the problems or issues being encountered by the Muslim community, without fear or favour.
I'm an Indian and I will be the first person to die for my country. The Indian constitution has empowered me to express my views on any subject including the backwardness or injustices being done to any community in the country, including the Muslim community. Then why should I be afraid of exercising my constitutional right and even think of deciding the level of my 'Muslimness' that I will exhibit. I can be both, a '100 per cent Muslim' as well as '100 per cent Indian'.
I think we can clear lot of apprehensions about the Muslim community, if we speak up. Indian Muslims should not be secretive about anything. They have nothing to hide. But, while highlighting their problems, they must ensure that they never speak against any other community or religion or spread any kind of hatred.
Saturday, February 06, 2010
Tuesday, January 26, 2010
No Role for Muslims in India Inc.
Today India celebrated its 60th Republic Day. In her ceremonial address to the nation on 25th January, President Pratibha Patil pointed out that India was the fourth largest economy in the world in terms of purchasing power parity. She also hoped that India was on target for achieving a double-digit growth rate.
But shockingly, the Muslim community is not likely to play any role in achieving this target. Despite constituting 13.4 per cent of the total population (2001 Census), the Muslim contribution in shaping the Indian economy is very minimal. Their participation in the industrial, agricultural or corporate sectors is almost nil. It may sound too pessimistic, but the Indian Muslims themselves, especially the youth, it seems, are not interested in playing an active role in second industrial revolution that is brewing.
The Forbes India magazine in its December edition published the list of 100 richest people in India. Of them, only three were Muslims. With a net worth of $ 14.9 billion Wipro chairman Azim Premji ranked 4th while Yusuf Hamied of Cipla with $ 1.89 billion ranked 27th and Shahid Balwa of DB Reality with $ 1.02 billion stood 50th among the 100 richest people. Interestingly, all three of them are not first generation entrepreneurs. They inherited wealth and businesses from their fathers. However, they expanded and strengthened those businesses to make it to the list of 100 richest people in India.
I was recently going through the list of top 500 companies of 2008 & 2009 in India and to my surprise, not even one per cent of those companies are owned by Muslims. All these companies are listed either with the Bombay Stock Exchange or National Stock Exchange, or both. With varied business activities, they are playing a crucial role in boosting India's economy and giving employment to lakhs of people. But sadly, the Indian Muslims are not making any (significant) contribution in any of these sectors. Similarly, not even two per cent of the non-listed companies are owned by the Muslims. Though Muslims own small or mid-size businesses in some cities like Mumbai, Delhi and Hyderabad, but they are all proprietors and they show no inclination to expand and grow at the national level.
Though the Indian corporate world is not divided, at least for now, on religious lines, but the statistics show that the presence of Muslim community here is dismal. Contrary to this, several all other communities, including the minority communities like the Christians have made a place for themselves in the corporate world.
Quoting official reports, the Indian Muslims often complain that they are being denied an opportunity to do business. Justice Rajinder Sachar in his report mentioned that the average amount of bank loan disbursed to the Muslims is 2/3rd of the amount disbursed to other minorities. In some cases it is half. The pity is that, according to the report, many areas of Muslim concentration have been marked by many banks as 'negative' or 'red' zones where giving loans is not advisable. Therefore, Muslims engaged in self-employment ventures are not getting the required funds. However, I feel that these conditions are not applicable to all sections of
the Muslim society.
Today the Muslim community can be largely classified into three groups -- the rich, middle class and those living below poverty line. While the dependence of the middle class and BPL Muslims on government or bank funding is understood, although a majority of them are already engaged in self-employment activity, the rich muslims too are giving the same excuse to stay away from the corporate world. They are preferring to live in a 'safe mode'. They are investing money in real estate or other ventures with minimal risks. They seems to have stopped investing in a factory or other manufacturing units which also generates employment. They simply don't want to expand as they are afraid of losing money. This trend must go.
Hyderabad, for instance, is now a home to at least one thousands Muslim millionnaires. But shockingly, not many of them are engaged in organised business. Most of them, especially the NRIs, have made huge investments in the real estate. A few of them have also invested money in equity market. Investments in both the forms was not on long-term basis and therefore, they lost crores of rupees when the stock market fell and the real estate was hit by slowdown. These rich Muslims are not open to the idea of starting their own business on professional lines, to generate both employment and also sustained revenue. Instead, they would invest and lose money in some fly-by-night companies like Alfalah, which duped hundreds of depositors in 1999.
If the rich Muslims learn to take calculated risk and enter the corporate world, then they can generate both employment and profits, besides being a part of India growth story.
But shockingly, the Muslim community is not likely to play any role in achieving this target. Despite constituting 13.4 per cent of the total population (2001 Census), the Muslim contribution in shaping the Indian economy is very minimal. Their participation in the industrial, agricultural or corporate sectors is almost nil. It may sound too pessimistic, but the Indian Muslims themselves, especially the youth, it seems, are not interested in playing an active role in second industrial revolution that is brewing.
The Forbes India magazine in its December edition published the list of 100 richest people in India. Of them, only three were Muslims. With a net worth of $ 14.9 billion Wipro chairman Azim Premji ranked 4th while Yusuf Hamied of Cipla with $ 1.89 billion ranked 27th and Shahid Balwa of DB Reality with $ 1.02 billion stood 50th among the 100 richest people. Interestingly, all three of them are not first generation entrepreneurs. They inherited wealth and businesses from their fathers. However, they expanded and strengthened those businesses to make it to the list of 100 richest people in India.
I was recently going through the list of top 500 companies of 2008 & 2009 in India and to my surprise, not even one per cent of those companies are owned by Muslims. All these companies are listed either with the Bombay Stock Exchange or National Stock Exchange, or both. With varied business activities, they are playing a crucial role in boosting India's economy and giving employment to lakhs of people. But sadly, the Indian Muslims are not making any (significant) contribution in any of these sectors. Similarly, not even two per cent of the non-listed companies are owned by the Muslims. Though Muslims own small or mid-size businesses in some cities like Mumbai, Delhi and Hyderabad, but they are all proprietors and they show no inclination to expand and grow at the national level.
Though the Indian corporate world is not divided, at least for now, on religious lines, but the statistics show that the presence of Muslim community here is dismal. Contrary to this, several all other communities, including the minority communities like the Christians have made a place for themselves in the corporate world.
Quoting official reports, the Indian Muslims often complain that they are being denied an opportunity to do business. Justice Rajinder Sachar in his report mentioned that the average amount of bank loan disbursed to the Muslims is 2/3rd of the amount disbursed to other minorities. In some cases it is half. The pity is that, according to the report, many areas of Muslim concentration have been marked by many banks as 'negative' or 'red' zones where giving loans is not advisable. Therefore, Muslims engaged in self-employment ventures are not getting the required funds. However, I feel that these conditions are not applicable to all sections of
the Muslim society.
Today the Muslim community can be largely classified into three groups -- the rich, middle class and those living below poverty line. While the dependence of the middle class and BPL Muslims on government or bank funding is understood, although a majority of them are already engaged in self-employment activity, the rich muslims too are giving the same excuse to stay away from the corporate world. They are preferring to live in a 'safe mode'. They are investing money in real estate or other ventures with minimal risks. They seems to have stopped investing in a factory or other manufacturing units which also generates employment. They simply don't want to expand as they are afraid of losing money. This trend must go.
Hyderabad, for instance, is now a home to at least one thousands Muslim millionnaires. But shockingly, not many of them are engaged in organised business. Most of them, especially the NRIs, have made huge investments in the real estate. A few of them have also invested money in equity market. Investments in both the forms was not on long-term basis and therefore, they lost crores of rupees when the stock market fell and the real estate was hit by slowdown. These rich Muslims are not open to the idea of starting their own business on professional lines, to generate both employment and also sustained revenue. Instead, they would invest and lose money in some fly-by-night companies like Alfalah, which duped hundreds of depositors in 1999.
If the rich Muslims learn to take calculated risk and enter the corporate world, then they can generate both employment and profits, besides being a part of India growth story.
Monday, January 25, 2010
Why Hind Muslims?
Before I start writing on the subjects relevant to the Muslim community in India, let me clarify on the title of this blog. It is "H-I-N-D Muslims" and it should not be read or mistaken as "Hindu-Muslims". Frankly speaking, I don't need to give this clarification. But like all other Indian Muslims, I got habituated to the practice of giving clarification, even when it is not required or asked.
We 'clarify' that we love our motherland. We 'clarify' that we are not anti-nationals. We 'clarify' that we don't support terrorism. We 'clarify' that we don't have anything to do Osama or Al-Qaeda. We 'clarify' that we are not responsible for all the wrongs that are happening in the world in the name of Islam. None of these clarifications are required, but still we give clarifications on innumerable issues.
However, coming back to the blog title, 'Hind Muslims' was not my first choice. I tried to get other titles like the 'Indian Muslims' and 'Muslims in India', but those titles were already registered with the blogger. Though I was a bit upset, but like many other Indian Muslims, I was not disappointed. It reminded me of my college days. I applied for admission in three best intermediate colleges in Hyderabad. Despite having over 70 per cent marks, I failed to get a seat. But many students with less than 50 per cent marks got admission, due to reservation. However, I satisfied myself by taking admission in a little known junior college. I just did what thousands of other Muslim students do every year -- get satisfied with whatever they get.
As you are aware, the word "Hind" means "India". The slogan "Jai Hind" played a revolutionary role during the freedom struggle. But since "Hind" is an Urdu word, its usage has been confined after independence. Presently, it is being used only on two occasions -- Independence Day and Republic Day. After hoisting the national flag and reciting national anthem, everyone shouts "Jai Hind" thrice and that's all. I hope that this blog would help at least a few thousand people to understand that India is also known as "Hind".
After registering the title "HindMuslims", I realised that the more appropriate title could have been "Hindustanimuslims". It would have had more clarity. But it would have been a too long title and would have looked boring. Instead of "Hind", people would have been required to type six more alphabets to type "hindustani". Therefore, 'hindmuslims' looked appropriate to me.
I pray to Allah to give me knowledge, wisdom and courage to write on the issues concerning the Indian Muslims through this blog. Amin.
We 'clarify' that we love our motherland. We 'clarify' that we are not anti-nationals. We 'clarify' that we don't support terrorism. We 'clarify' that we don't have anything to do Osama or Al-Qaeda. We 'clarify' that we are not responsible for all the wrongs that are happening in the world in the name of Islam. None of these clarifications are required, but still we give clarifications on innumerable issues.
However, coming back to the blog title, 'Hind Muslims' was not my first choice. I tried to get other titles like the 'Indian Muslims' and 'Muslims in India', but those titles were already registered with the blogger. Though I was a bit upset, but like many other Indian Muslims, I was not disappointed. It reminded me of my college days. I applied for admission in three best intermediate colleges in Hyderabad. Despite having over 70 per cent marks, I failed to get a seat. But many students with less than 50 per cent marks got admission, due to reservation. However, I satisfied myself by taking admission in a little known junior college. I just did what thousands of other Muslim students do every year -- get satisfied with whatever they get.
As you are aware, the word "Hind" means "India". The slogan "Jai Hind" played a revolutionary role during the freedom struggle. But since "Hind" is an Urdu word, its usage has been confined after independence. Presently, it is being used only on two occasions -- Independence Day and Republic Day. After hoisting the national flag and reciting national anthem, everyone shouts "Jai Hind" thrice and that's all. I hope that this blog would help at least a few thousand people to understand that India is also known as "Hind".
After registering the title "HindMuslims", I realised that the more appropriate title could have been "Hindustanimuslims". It would have had more clarity. But it would have been a too long title and would have looked boring. Instead of "Hind", people would have been required to type six more alphabets to type "hindustani". Therefore, 'hindmuslims' looked appropriate to me.
I pray to Allah to give me knowledge, wisdom and courage to write on the issues concerning the Indian Muslims through this blog. Amin.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Posts
